When the former defender stepped into the role as the club's boss in January, he faced a severe lack of time to settle in. A packed fixture schedule meant a gradual introduction to his team was impossible.
Local press warned of the difficulties he would confront, especially overseeing a dressing room full of some of soccer's largest egos.
Yet establishing positive connections with the footballers did not seem to faze the former Liverpool defender.
"It's not an aspect that worries me a lot," the coach remarked at his inaugural news conference.
Eight weeks since, he says those rapports are growing stronger and the performances on the pitch are reflecting that.
Establishing Connections
In March, the Madrid boss steered his side to triumphs against teams led by elite managers: the Portuguese manager's the Lisbon side, Pep Guardiola's City and the Argentine's Atletico.
Los Merengues are still four points behind La Liga leaders their arch-rivals, with a crucial upcoming Clasico in May, while their Champions League campaign continues with a quarter-final tie against Bayern Munich.
Real's form are getting better and the dynamic between the manager and players are building.
"I'm getting to know the individuals more and more," said the head coach following Real Madrid's 3-2 victory against rivals Atletico Madrid recently.
"I came in at a time when I virtually had no time to observe the squad, to grasp where they operated best, and to witness how they mixed with one another."
He acknowledged the timing of his hiring presented new challenges.
"For me, it's not easy to arrive mid-season and analyze how the team works, and that is precisely what has transformed over these two months," he went on.
"Now I know my charges on and off the pitch, where I can extract the best output from them, and where I can make adjustments."
Plaudits for Vinicius Jr
A key individual flourishing under Arbeloa is the Brazilian winger.
He has started 16 of Arbeloa's 17 matches in charge, with his scoring rate also seeing a dramatic uptick - he has netted 11 goals under Arbeloa, compared to registering just six in 27 outings under Xabi Alonso.
The coach has concentrated on rebuilding the forward's morale, encouraging him to express himself and show his flair rather than restricting him in terms of tactics.
"I am fortunate to have Vini, he's loved by the supporters. We want to see the Vinicius who loves the game, who smiles, who celebrates… that is the player I want to see," Arbeloa said in his first press conference in charge.
That approach differs from accounts of tension under Alonso, with Vinicius reportedly saying "I will quit this team" after being substituted in last match against Barcelona.
The new boss has publicly stood up for him, stating clearly he is has the total confidence by the coaching staff and the dressing room.
"He is among the most dangerous players, if not the deadliest, in the world today and he epitomizes what a this club's star is," said the manager.
Vinicius put talks about his future at the club in abeyance last summer but, last week, he affirmed his loyalty to the club.
"I'm only thinking about Real Madrid and remaining there for a long time," he informed the media before Brazil's friendly with the French team.
Fede Valverde Finds His Best Form Again
The Uruguayan midfielder's performances has also surged since Arbeloa took charge.
Under Alonso, he managed three goals and seven goal contributions from 31 games.
Since the manager's arrival, he has started all 17 of his games, scoring on seven occasions and registering five key passes.
A major reason has been a change in role back into midfield.
Throughout Alonso's time in charge, Valverde at times had difficulty trying to cement a starting spot in his preferred position, being used in unfamiliar roles such as right-back.
Although the decision was partly because of fitness issues to teammates, Valverde's frustration was clear. "I wasn't made to be a defender," he stated.
Yet now, returned to his natural habitat, the midfielder is prospering.
He has netted six strikes in just a month, including a three-goal haul against Manchester City and a decisive strike in a 3–2 victory over Atletico Madrid.
More Players, More Potential?
Arbeloa's experience as boss of Real Madrid's B team has made incorporating young players into the first team feel effortless, so it was natural to anticipate him to give promising youngsters opportunities.
This was seen particularly when Real Madrid faced Elche earlier this month and the coach provided opportunities to six Castilla players.
One player, in particular, has quickly established himself as one of Arbeloa's most exciting proteges.
At just 18 years and 226 days, he became the youngest player in the club's records to begin a match twice in the European Cup knockout stages, beating a previous mark by 10 days.
Questioned what it signified to see several academy graduates on the pitch, he couldn't mask his delight.
"I think I can be content after a night like this one," he remarked.
"I was just speaking with two of them, who were the first players I managed when they were 13 or 14, and to be able to give them the opportunity to perform at the Santiago Bernabeu is a fantastic achievement for me."
While the coach might be familiar with the Castilla players, he concedes fitness setbacks have curtailed his exposure